Lets get two categories going. Category 1) >100k attackers 2) <100k attackers
Post your battle reports and tell if you used any horns, medicine, and the attack level of your hero.
Here is a starter: http://battle7.evony.com/default.html?logfile/5a/0a/89/1f/5a0a891fad59be9a15708824d4119191.xml
209 Attack Hero, no horns, no pennicilyn

wow i wish i could accire a mics script
battlew12.evony.com/default.html?logfile/20090905/3c/17/3c172968b9eb69b278e1ecf6884daef6.xml
no horns but used penicillin
took 10 nations medals and 10 justice medals
hero attack lvl145
use 95k archers 1k swords pikes and warriors
and a 200+ attack hero 2-4k archer loses
and 2k trans of course to take resources
battle34.evony.com/default.html?logfile/20091029/d7/b6/d7b623d2d3c854c4a18d954797ae44c5.xml
used a war horn and corslet. timed my attacks and took it within 1 min from first strike to last.
attack level of hero 180.
battle41.evony.com/default.html?logfile/20091130/a4/e1/a4e1a5b309ce7f80caaa1f2a0ddefa3b.xml